Practice areas · Assault offences · New South Wales

Charged with grievous bodily harm in NSW.

Grievous bodily harm, or GBH, is really serious injury. NSW has three levels of GBH charge, and the difference between them is the accused's state of mind. Causing GBH with intent under s 33 of the Crimes Act 1900 (NSW) carries 25 years and a 7-year standard non-parole period. Reckless GBH under s 35 carries 10 years, or 14 years in company. Causing GBH by an unlawful or negligent act under s 54 carries 2 years.

  • Maximum (s 33)25 yearsWound or cause GBH with intent
  • Standard non-parole period7 yearss 33; not for offenders under 18
  • Reckless GBH (s 35)10 years14 years in company
  • Negligent GBH (s 54)2 yearsUnlawful or negligent act or omission

The legislative source.

Section 33(1) Crimes Act 1900 (NSW) · Wounding or grievous bodily harm with intent
A person who (a) wounds any person, or (b) causes grievous bodily harm to any person, with intent to cause grievous bodily harm to that or any other person is guilty of an offence.
Maximum penalty: imprisonment for 25 years.

Section 54 · Causing grievous bodily harm
Whosoever by any unlawful or negligent act, or omission, causes grievous bodily harm to any person, shall be liable to imprisonment for two years.

Section 4 of the Crimes Act says grievous bodily harm includes any permanent or serious disfiguring of the person, the destruction of the foetus of a pregnant woman (other than in the course of a medical procedure or a lawful termination), and any grievous bodily disease. Beyond that list, the words take their ordinary meaning: really serious harm. Fractures, serious internal injuries, brain injury and serious facial scarring are common examples.

The three levels of GBH charge.

ChargeState of mindMaximumStandard non-parole period
s 33(1) wound or GBH with intentIntent to cause GBH25 years7 years
s 33(2) wound or GBH to resist arrestIntent to resist or prevent lawful arrest or detention25 years7 years
s 35(1) reckless GBH in companyReckless as to causing actual bodily harm14 years5 years
s 35(2) reckless GBHReckless as to causing actual bodily harm10 years4 years
s 54 causing GBHUnlawful or negligent act or omission2 yearsNone

Reckless wounding and reckless GBH under s 35 have their own page: reckless wounding and reckless GBH in NSW.

What the prosecution must prove under s 33(1).

ElementWhat it means
A wound or GBHA wound breaks both layers of the skin. GBH is really serious injury, including the matters listed in s 4.
Caused by the accusedThe accused's act caused the injury. Causation is in issue where the injury came from a fall, another person, or a later event.
Intent to cause GBHThe accused meant to cause really serious injury to that person or another person. Intent is usually proved by inference from the weapon, the force, the words spoken and where the blows landed.
Not in self-defenceOnce self-defence is raised, the prosecution must prove beyond reasonable doubt that the accused was not acting in self-defence (ss 418 and 419).

If the jury is not satisfied of the intent but is satisfied of an offence under s 35, it can return that verdict instead (s 33(3)). Section 33 is also listed in s 428B as an offence of specific intent. That matters where the accused was intoxicated, because Part 11A of the Act then governs how evidence of intoxication bears on whether the intent was formed. Our news note on wounding with intent under s 33 covers the intent element in more detail.

Penalties and likely outcomes.

Maximum penalties.

Twenty-five years for s 33. Ten years for reckless GBH under s 35(2), and 14 years in company under s 35(1). Two years for causing GBH by an unlawful or negligent act under s 54.

Is there a minimum sentence for GBH?

There is no mandatory minimum sentence for GBH in NSW. Section 33 carries a standard non-parole period of 7 years (Crimes (Sentencing Procedure) Act 1999 (NSW) s 54A and the Table to Part 4 Division 1A, item 4). The standard non-parole period represents the non-parole period for an offence in the middle of the range of objective seriousness (s 54A(2)). The court takes it into account, but it is not a floor. The court must record its reasons where it sets a non-parole period longer or shorter than the standard (s 54B(3)). The standard non-parole period does not apply to an offender who was under 18 when the offence was committed (s 54D(3)).

Which court.

Section 33 is not listed in Schedule 1 of the Criminal Procedure Act 1986 (NSW), so it is dealt with on indictment in the District Court. Sections 35 and 54 are Table 1 offences: they stay in the Local Court unless the prosecution or the accused elects to take them to the District Court. The Local Court limit is 2 years for each offence.

Likely outcomes.

A conviction under s 33 carries a real risk of full-time imprisonment, given the 25-year maximum and the standard non-parole period. The outcome turns on the injury, any weapon, planning, the offender's role, and the subjective case. A s 54 charge can arise from a workplace incident, a sporting injury or careless conduct, and the full range of sentencing options is available.

Defences and arguments worth running.

Self-defence.

Section 418 of the Crimes Act provides a complete defence where the accused believed the conduct was necessary to defend themselves or another person, and the conduct was a reasonable response in the circumstances as they perceived them. The prosecution must disprove self-defence beyond reasonable doubt (s 419). See our note on self-defence under section 418.

No intent to cause GBH.

On a s 33 charge the intent is usually the real contest. A single punch, a push, or a blow struck in a scuffle may not support an inference that the accused meant to cause really serious injury. If intent is not proved, the alternative is s 35, with a much lower maximum.

The injury is not GBH.

Medical records are tested. Where the injury does not reach really serious harm, the charge may fall to assault occasioning actual bodily harm under s 59. See AOABH in NSW.

Causation and identity.

In group incidents the Crown must prove who caused the injury, or that the accused was part of a joint criminal enterprise. Where the injury came from a fall or a later event, causation is in issue. Our note on group assaults and joint criminal enterprise explains how liability is shared.

Negligence (s 54).

A s 54 charge requires the Crown to prove an unlawful or negligent act or omission that caused the injury. Whether the conduct was negligent is often the main issue.

What we do for clients facing this charge.

GBH charges move quickly. Bail is the first step, and police often oppose release on a s 33 charge. We prepare the release application under the Bail Act 2013 (NSW) with an address, conditions and, where relevant, treatment in place.

Next is the brief. The medical evidence, CCTV, body-worn video and witness statements are read against each element. In many s 33 matters the contest is intent. Where the evidence supports only recklessness, we put a written case to the prosecution for the charge to be replaced with s 35, which has a lower maximum and can be finalised in the Local Court.

If the matter goes to trial, counsel is briefed early and the defence is built around the medical evidence, self-defence and the intent element. On a plea, the sentencing case addresses the standard non-parole period directly, with psychological evidence, references and evidence of rehabilitation.

Frequently asked.

What is grievous bodily harm in NSW?

Grievous bodily harm is really serious injury. Section 4 of the Crimes Act 1900 (NSW) says it includes any permanent or serious disfiguring of the person, the destruction of a foetus (other than in a medical procedure or a lawful termination), and any grievous bodily disease. Fractures and serious internal injuries are common examples.

What is the minimum sentence for grievous bodily harm in NSW?

There is no mandatory minimum. For wounding or GBH with intent under s 33, the standard non-parole period is 7 years. That figure is a reference point for an offence in the middle of the range of objective seriousness. The court can set a longer or shorter non-parole period and must record its reasons when it does. It does not apply to an offender who was under 18 at the time.

What does intent to cause grievous bodily harm mean?

The prosecution must prove the accused meant to cause really serious injury, not only that serious injury happened. Intent is usually inferred from the circumstances: the weapon, the number and force of the blows, where they landed, and what was said. If the jury is not satisfied of intent, it can convict of reckless GBH or reckless wounding under s 35 instead (s 33(3)).

What is the difference between GBH and ABH?

Actual bodily harm is injury that is more than transient or trifling, such as bruising or swelling. Grievous bodily harm is really serious injury. Assault occasioning actual bodily harm under s 59 carries 5 years, or 7 years in company. Wounding or GBH with intent under s 33 carries 25 years.

Is a GBH charge dealt with in the Local Court?

It depends on the charge. Section 33 (GBH with intent) is dealt with in the District Court. Reckless GBH under s 35 and causing GBH under s 54 are Table 1 offences: they stay in the Local Court unless the prosecution or the accused elects to go to the District Court. The Local Court limit is 2 years for each offence.

What is negligent GBH under section 54?

Section 54 makes it an offence to cause grievous bodily harm to any person by an unlawful or negligent act or omission. The maximum is 2 years. It covers serious injury caused without any intent to harm. It is a Table 1 offence and can be finalised in the Local Court.

Can I claim self-defence to a GBH charge?

Yes. Self-defence under s 418 is a complete defence. Once it is raised, the prosecution must prove beyond reasonable doubt that the accused was not acting in self-defence (s 419).

Charged with this offence? Get advice before entering a plea.

A 30-minute initial conference. Confidential. The brief is read. The realistic options are laid out. No retainer is opened until you decide to proceed.

Book a confidential consult 0421 717 019

This page authored by

Aaron Kernaghan · Senior Solicitor Advocate, Brady & Associates Lawyers

High Court of Australia · 26+ years in NSW and ACT criminal practice.